Open-source software is gaining immense popularity, and even Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) are embracing open-source code for increased transparency. With over 100 million developers contributing to the open-source community, the likelihood of identifying and patching vulnerabilities is significantly higher.
Proton VPN and Mullvad are two of the leading VPNs on the market, and both are open-source. You can examine their code on GitHub (Proton VPN and Mullvad) to verify the absence of hidden logging or undisclosed data collection practices.
Transparency is crucial, but you also need a fast, user-friendly VPN that can bypass geo-restrictions while safeguarding your privacy. Let’s compare Proton VPN and Mullvad to determine which one best suits your needs and budget.
Specifications
| Feature | Proton VPN | Mullvad |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android | Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android |
| Devices | 10 | 5 |
| Support | 24/7 Live Chat | |
| Free Version? | Yes | No |
Pricing and Subscription Tiers
alt text: Proton VPN Plus offers affordable pricing with various subscription lengths.
Proton VPN offers a compelling free version with minimal limitations, making it one of the best free VPNs available. It doesn’t restrict data usage or connection time. However, the free version only provides servers in the U.S., the Netherlands, and Japan. To access geo-blocked content from other regions, a paid subscription is required.
Proton VPN offers monthly, annual, and two-year subscriptions, with longer terms providing better value. The two-year plan costs $108 (equivalent to $4.50 per month), and the annual plan is $60 ($5 per month). A monthly plan is also available for $10, suitable for infrequent use.
A Proton VPN Plus subscription unlocks access to servers in over 110 countries, including less congested servers. It also enables advanced features like Secure Core servers, which route your traffic through two servers for enhanced privacy.
alt text: Mullvad VPN offers a simple pricing structure with a monthly fee of 5 euros.
Mullvad keeps it simple with a single subscription option: 5 euros per month (approximately $5.27 USD, subject to exchange rate fluctuations). There’s no free tier. Mullvad’s monthly cost is comparable to Proton VPN’s annual plan and nearly matches its two-year plan. However, cost isn’t the only factor to consider.
Feature Comparison
alt text: Achieving high download speeds with Proton VPN Plus, even on a remote server.
Connection speed is paramount for streaming, torrenting, or using web applications. Proton VPN Plus delivered consistently fast speeds globally. Nearby server connections exceeded 50% of my base download speed. Even when connecting to a server on the opposite side of the world, download speeds remained respectable at 255 Mbps.
Mullvad’s connection was reliable, but speeds fluctuated more depending on the server location. While I achieved impressive download speeds of 521 Mbps from a nearby server and good speeds in Europe, other locations were less consistent.
alt text: Mullvad VPN demonstrating good upload and download speeds with a nearby server.
While distant server connections are inherently slower for any VPN, Mullvad’s performance in some locations, like Canada, was noticeably slower than expected. Proton VPN Plus offers more consistent speeds and provides advanced options for optimizing your connection.
Proton VPN also offers a convenient browser extension that works independently from the main application. This allows for quick connection switching within the browser without affecting other applications’ internet access. While Mullvad and Proton VPN Plus offer split-tunneling for similar functionality, Proton VPN’s browser extension is more user-friendly for web browsing.
Customer Support
alt text: Proton VPN Plus offers 24/7 live chat support for subscribers.
Proton VPN Plus provides 24/7 live chat support, a valuable resource for new VPN users. Responses are quick and helpful, addressing questions about app usage, terminology, or account issues.
Mullvad relies on email support, which can be slower. Response times can vary, but expect a delay. While not necessarily a problem for non-urgent inquiries, Proton VPN offers a more responsive support experience.
Privacy and Security
Both Proton VPN and Mullvad boast excellent privacy track records, strong transparency, and no major security breaches. Both are leaders in privacy protection.
Proton VPN is based in Switzerland, a country outside of major intelligence alliances. Mullvad operates from Sweden, which is subject to Fourteen Eyes surveillance requests.
However, data requests are irrelevant if there’s no data to collect. Both companies maintain a strict no-logs policy, verified by independent audits.
Mullvad takes anonymity a step further, allowing users to create accounts without an email address and offering payment options like Bitcoin and cash to avoid financial tracking. Proton VPN also accepts Bitcoin and cash, but an email address is required for account creation. While equally secure, Mullvad offers the ultimate in privacy.
Making the Right Choice
Both Proton VPN and Mullvad are excellent VPN services. Choosing between them comes down to your priorities.
Mullvad prioritizes anonymity, allowing you to use their service without revealing your identity. Its monthly price is also lower than Proton VPN Plus. If you prioritize anonymity and occasional VPN use, Mullvad offers excellent value.
Proton VPN Plus provides consistently fast speeds, advanced features, and responsive customer support. Overall, Proton VPN Plus is a strong choice and a top contender in the VPN market.
