Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) has seen a massive resurgence, leading to a surge in related media like films and video games. Wizards of the Coast and Hasbro are capitalizing on this renewed interest, even revamping D&D 5e with planned releases in 2024 and 2025. However, these changes haven’t resonated with all fans, with some preferring legacy content and others abandoning the game altogether due to past controversies. Luckily, the world of tabletop role-playing games (TTRPGs) is vast and vibrant. This article explores seven compelling alternatives to D&D, offering diverse settings, mechanics, and experiences.
Pathfinder: A Familiar Yet Distinct Fantasy Realm
Pathfinder characters fighting a dragon
Pathfinder, developed by Paizo, is a classic D&D alternative, sharing a similar fantasy setting and gameplay mechanics. Originating as a D&D 3.5e derivative before the release of 4th edition, Pathfinder retains the detailed character customization and complex rulesets of its predecessor. Often referred to as “D&D 3.75” due to its similarities, Pathfinder has since evolved into its own unique system while still providing a comfortable transition for D&D players.
Pathfinder 2e boasts 23 base classes, numerous prestige classes, and over 30 ancestries (races), offering a wide range of character options. Familiar elements like questing, storytelling, miniatures, dice, and maps will resonate with D&D players. Paizo’s regular release of new adventures and sourcebooks ensures a constantly evolving world. While some adjustment is needed, Pathfinder offers a less restrictive and equally engaging fantasy experience.
Daggerheart: Collaborative Storytelling with Hope and Fear
Daggerheart Galapa ancestry character
Developed by Critical Role, Daggerheart presents a unique take on fantasy TTRPGs. Emerging from the popular D&D streaming show, Daggerheart combines familiar fantasy themes with innovative mechanics. The dual dice system, Hope and Fear, creates a dynamic where the Game Master (GM) takes on a more active role. Player rolls influence the GM’s resources, allowing them to interact with the party in compelling ways. Launching in Spring 2025 with eight classes and 18 ancestries, Daggerheart promises a fresh and collaborative storytelling experience.
BREAK!! RPG: Anime-Inspired Adventure in a Post-Apocalyptic World
BREAK!! RPG party
BREAK!! RPG offers a distinctive anime-inspired aesthetic, drawing inspiration from Studio Ghibli, The Legend of Zelda, and classic SNES RPGs. Its streamlined ruleset, focus on quick gameplay, and post-apocalyptic setting distinguish it from traditional fantasy TTRPGs. With eight callings (classes) and eleven species, including the option to play as a “Dimensional Stray Human” (isekai), BREAK!! RPG embraces its anime influences. The game blends problem-solving, combat, character progression, and loot gathering, offering a vibrant and accessible experience.
Dark Heresy: Grim Adventures in the Warhammer 40,000 Universe
Dark Heresy acolytes
Dark Heresy plunges players into the grim darkness of the Warhammer 40,000 universe. As acolytes serving an Inquisitor, players fight against heresy and xenos threats. The game emphasizes fast character creation and dynamic rules encompassing combat, stealth, and social interactions. With seven core classes and options for xeno races, Dark Heresy offers a gritty and challenging experience. While newer Warhammer 40,000 RPGs exist, Dark Heresy remains a popular choice due to its rich content and immersive setting.
Mutants & Masterminds: Unleash Your Inner Superhero
Mutants and Masterminds heroes
Mutants & Masterminds caters to superhero enthusiasts, allowing players to create their own heroes or recreate iconic characters from the comics. The game excels at narrative-driven gameplay and power fantasy fulfillment. Instead of traditional classes, Mutants & Masterminds uses a power level system, enabling deep customization. While character creation and encounter design require more effort, the flexibility and depth of the system reward players with a truly personalized superhero experience.
Liminal Horror: Survive the Ordinary Turned Extraordinary
Liminal horror eyes in the darkness
Liminal Horror offers a grounded and realistic horror experience. Players take on the roles of ordinary individuals facing extraordinary circumstances, often inspired by stories like Alan Wake or True Detective. The rules-lite system is accessible and adaptable, allowing for easy homebrew content creation. Survival is paramount, and not all characters may make it through the horrors they encounter. Liminal Horror’s flexibility enables diverse narratives and provides a great entry point for players new to TTRPGs.
Cyberpunk RED: High-Tech Lowlife in Night City
Cyberpunk Night City scene
Cyberpunk RED serves as a prequel to the video game Cyberpunk 2077, set in Night City in 2045 after the 4th Corporate War. Players navigate the dangerous streets as survivors trying to make a living in a dystopian future. With eight roles (classes) and extensive lore, Cyberpunk RED provides a rich and immersive experience. The streamlined gameplay retains depth, especially in its updated Netrunning mechanics. Whether using pre-written modules or creating their own stories, players can explore the vibrant and dangerous world of Night City.
The world of TTRPGs is thriving, with numerous alternatives to D&D offering unique and engaging experiences. These seven examples represent a small fraction of the diverse options available, encouraging players to explore new worlds and mechanics beyond the familiar realms of D&D.
