The electric vehicle market is booming, and two prominent contenders are the BMW i4 and Tesla Model 3. Both offer compelling features, sleek designs, and impressive performance. But which EV sedan is the right choice for you? This guide dives deep into the differences and similarities between the BMW i4 and Tesla Model 3, helping you make an informed decision.
Design and Aesthetics
A 2022 BMW i4 M50 in a driveway.
The design philosophies of these two EVs are strikingly different. The Tesla Model 3 boasts a sleek, minimalist aesthetic, instantly recognizable as a Tesla. Its smooth lines and futuristic profile have become synonymous with the brand. However, some argue that the design is becoming somewhat dated, considering its lineage dating back to the Model S.
The BMW i4, on the other hand, embraces a more traditional BMW design language. Its curved lines, signature kidney grille, and iconic BMW logo exude a classic, yet modern, appeal. The large kidney grille, a recent point of contention for some, remains a defining feature. Various i4 models offer subtle design tweaks, primarily concerning accents and wheels. Ultimately, the “better” design comes down to personal preference.
Interior and Technology
The interior of a Tesla Model Y.
Stepping inside, the differences continue. The Model 3’s interior embraces minimalism, featuring a large central touchscreen that controls virtually every vehicle function. While a few physical buttons remain on the steering wheel, the touchscreen dominates the user experience.
The BMW i4 presents a more traditional interior, with physical buttons and knobs alongside a large display for navigation and infotainment. The driver-focused layout may require some adjustment for those accustomed to Tesla’s minimalist approach. The i4’s interior also projects a more premium feel, with comfortable seats and luxurious materials. However, many appreciate the simplicity and uncluttered nature of the Model 3’s interior.
Tesla’s software prowess shines through in the Model 3. The intuitive user interface and smooth performance set it apart. Over-the-air updates ensure that the system remains current with new features and bug fixes.
The BMW i4 relies on the iDrive system, which, while improved over the years, still lags behind Tesla’s software in terms of design and intuitiveness. The inclusion of Apple CarPlay and Android Auto offers alternative options for users who prefer these platforms.
Performance and Range
A 2022 BMW i4 M50 on pavement near a church.
Both the Model 3 and i4 offer exhilarating performance. The Model 3 comes in various configurations, with the Performance model boasting dual motors and a blistering 0-60 mph time of 3.1 seconds. The base model, with a single motor, achieves 0-60 mph in 5.8 seconds. Range varies from 272 miles for the base model to 315 miles for the Performance variant.
The BMW i4 lineup includes the eDrive35 (0-60 mph in 5.8 seconds), the eDrive40 (5.5 seconds), and the performance-oriented M50 (3.7 seconds). Range spans from 270 miles for the M50 to 335 miles for the eDrive40. Both vehicles deliver the instant acceleration and quiet operation characteristic of EVs. For those prioritizing range, the Model 3 Performance or the i4 eDrive40 are compelling options.
Price and Availability
A Tesla Model 3 electric car.
The Tesla Model 3 holds a price advantage, starting around $40,390, with the Performance model priced around $56,390. The BMW i4 begins at $51,400 for the eDrive35 and climbs to $67,300 for the M50, with options potentially increasing the cost further.
The Model 3 enjoys wider availability compared to the i4, which is currently sold in select markets.
Conclusion
The choice between the BMW i4 and Tesla Model 3 depends on individual priorities. The Model 3 offers sleek design, impressive performance, and a user-friendly software experience at a competitive price. The BMW i4 delivers a more traditional driving experience, a premium interior, and near-matching performance, albeit at a higher price point. Consider your preferences for design, technology, performance, and budget to determine which EV sedan best suits your needs.
