The new M4 MacBook Pro models boast impressive performance, but an iFixit teardown reveals persistent repairability issues. While some internal components have been redesigned, including a larger heatsink and relocated logic board elements, key obstacles remain for DIY repairs.
Limited Self-Repair Options
Despite easier port and battery replacements, Apple continues to use stretch-release adhesive for battery access, making removal challenging. iFixit describes the logic board removal process as “incredibly complex and tedious,” requiring navigating six stretch-release tabs near the trackpad and eight more on the sides.
The internal view of the M4 MacBook Pro.
Replacing the card reader or MagSafe connector requires advanced soldering skills and specialized tools. Further complicating matters, foam elements necessitate isopropyl alcohol for removal, and a complex network of gaskets and flex cables must be navigated before the logic board can be detached.
Software Locks and Part Matching
Apple’s part-matching strategy and calibration protocols pose significant challenges for repairs. Swapping displays or logic boards triggers software locks, potentially rendering cheaper, third-party replacements non-functional. This forces users to rely on expensive, Apple-approved parts for screen and Touch ID module replacements.
A Glimmer of Hope: Standalone Speaker Repairs
However, there’s a positive development. Apple is reportedly offering standalone speaker replacements for the 14-inch and 16-inch M4 MacBook Pros. Previously, replacing a faulty speaker required replacing the entire top case, a costly procedure. This change allows DIY enthusiasts to perform speaker repairs without exorbitant expenses.
Close-up of the speaker components.
Conclusion
While the M4 MacBook Pro offers impressive performance, its repairability remains a concern. Although standalone speaker replacements are a welcome improvement, significant challenges persist for self-repairs and third-party component replacements. Apple’s tight control over repairs and part matching continues to limit user options and potentially increase repair costs. This teardown highlights the ongoing tension between cutting-edge technology and consumer-friendly repairability.
