The critically acclaimed Soulslike, Lies of P, reimagines the classic Pinocchio tale with a dark twist, casting players as “P” battling hostile puppets in the unsettling city of Krat. A unique feature of this world is P’s ability to lie, a mechanic central to the gameplay. The game’s success has sparked excitement for future content, including a DLC and a sequel. However, the intriguing post-credit scene featuring Dorothy and her ruby slippers suggests a narrative direction best suited for a full sequel, rather than a DLC expansion.
The brief glimpse of Dorothy clicking her heels together three times atop a Krat rooftop, described as a “key” by an unknown group, hints at a connection between her and the experiments that birthed Krat. This raises questions about Dorothy’s role in this world and the possibility of her involvement in a similar experiment. Exploring these complex narrative threads requires ample space and depth, something a DLC might struggle to provide.
alt text: Enemies and a liar coffin in Lies of P
Lies of P, like many Soulslike games, relies heavily on environmental storytelling, demanding players piece together the narrative through item descriptions, fragmented dialogue, and careful observation. This deliberate pacing necessitates a larger canvas to fully realize a new storyline, especially one as potentially rich as Dorothy’s. A DLC could adequately continue P’s story, particularly if the ending featuring Sophia and her new puppet body is canonized. However, introducing and concluding an entirely new narrative arc within a DLC’s constraints could feel rushed and underdeveloped.
Why a Sequel Benefits Dorothy’s Story
Beyond narrative scope, a sequel allows for the development of unique gameplay mechanics centered around Dorothy. Her combat abilities could differ significantly from P’s, potentially incorporating the assistance of Toto. A new protagonist also opens up opportunities for exploring new locations, encountering new enemies and allies, and experiencing a fresh perspective on the world of Lies of P.
RELATED: Lies of P 2 May Feature Better Multiplayer Than Elden Ring
alt text: Sophia's puppet form in Lies of P
Confining Dorothy’s story to a DLC would severely limit the potential of this intriguing new character and the narrative possibilities she represents. A full sequel provides the necessary space to explore her unique story, develop her gameplay, and fully integrate her into the unsettling world of Lies of P. Expanding the lore and introducing a fresh perspective through Dorothy promises a richer and more compelling experience than a DLC could offer.
