MLB The Show has felt somewhat stagnant in recent years, delivering high-quality yet predictable iterations. While the expansion to Xbox and Nintendo Switch was welcome, true innovation seemed to be lacking. MLB The Show 23, however, steps up to the plate with significant additions, most notably the Negro Leagues Storylines mode, making it a compelling entry for baseball fans.
While the core gameplay, existing game modes, and updated 2023 MLB rosters remain largely unchanged from MLB The Show 22, the inclusion of the Negro Leagues Storylines mode is a game-changer. This mode addresses fan requests for more historical depth and adds an educational component that elevates the overall experience.
The Negro Leagues Storylines mode spotlights eight legendary players from the all-black baseball leagues that thrived until the mid-20th century. Players learn about icons like Jackie Robinson, Satchel Paige, and Buck O’Neil, as well as lesser-known stars like Hank Thompson. This mode isn’t just about playing key moments in these players’ careers; it’s about understanding their impact on the sport and American history. Narrated by Bob Kendrick, president of the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, the storytelling is captivating and informative, making this mode a must-play. The promise of future installments within this mode in subsequent MLB The Show titles is exciting.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Quqczz2pKoQ[/embed]
Diamond Dynasty, arguably MLB The Show 23‘s most popular mode, presents a mixed bag. While streamlined and offering more ways to compete with a custom-built team than ever before – including Mini Seasons, Ranked play, and Program missions – the accessibility of high-caliber “Diamond” tier players feels somewhat diluted. Their frequent availability diminishes the sense of accomplishment in building and upgrading a team. This could change as the Diamond Dynasty seasons progress, but the initial excitement of collecting players feels dampened. The integration of the World Baseball Classic into Diamond Dynasty, however, is a welcome addition. This year-long Program allows players to unlock international superstars like Shohei Ohtani, Munetaka Murakami, and Byung-ho Park, broadening the game’s scope and introducing players to global baseball talent.
mlb-the-show-23-turner.pngOther returning modes like Road to the Show, Franchise, and March to October remain largely unchanged from the previous iteration. While still enjoyable, they lack significant updates, suggesting that San Diego Studio might focus on these areas for The Show 24.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1puWWTezVHg[/embed]
MLB The Show 23 shines in its presentation. The new announcing team, introduced in the previous installment, offers a more diverse and less repetitive commentary experience. Gameplay animations are impressive, although the graphics still feel somewhat dated, likely due to the game’s availability on last-gen consoles and the Nintendo Switch. Hopefully, visual fidelity will receive a significant upgrade in the next installment.
Overall, MLB The Show 23 is a strong entry in the series, largely thanks to the Negro Leagues Storylines mode. This feature is not just entertaining but essential for any baseball enthusiast. While other game modes remain largely unchanged, the existing content still offers plenty of gameplay. Future installments would benefit from gameplay and graphical overhauls, but MLB The Show 23 delivers a satisfying experience for fans.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjSGWc0H9CU[/embed]
Rating: 4.5 out of 5
MLB The Show 23 is available now on PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X, Xbox One, and Nintendo Switch.
