NBA 2K games have a reputation for incremental changes, given the inherent limitations of iterating on real-world sports. However, NBA 2K23 attempts to break this mold, introducing new mechanics and a renewed focus on skill, albeit with some significant drawbacks. This review explores the highs and lows of NBA 2K23, focusing on its gameplay, content, and the ever-present shadow of microtransactions.
NBA 2K23 is arguably the most skill-based entry in the series’ recent history. Unlike NBA 2K22, where luck often played a significant role in making shots, 2K23 demands precision. The refined shot meter requires consistent green releases for successful baskets, encouraging players to develop their timing and shot selection rather than relying on chance. This emphasis on skill can be frustrating initially, especially for players accustomed to the more forgiving mechanics of previous iterations. However, it ultimately fosters a more rewarding experience, promoting strategic gameplay and teamwork. Passing becomes a crucial element, as players are encouraged to find the open teammate for a higher-percentage shot rather than forcing contested attempts.
nba-2k23-jordan.jpgNBA 2K23 Jordan Challenge recreates iconic moments.
Unfortunately, NBA 2K23 is also plagued by aggressive microtransactions, a long-standing issue in the series. The pay-to-win nature of the game becomes readily apparent in online modes like Rec, where players can spend real money on virtual currency (VC) to boost their character’s attributes. This creates a significant imbalance, pitting players who have invested heavily in VC against those who haven’t. From day one, players with overall ratings in the high 80s and low 90s are common in online play, a direct result of purchased upgrades. Starting characters, typically rated in the 60s, face a daunting uphill battle against these boosted opponents.
The impact of this system is particularly noticeable when starting the MyCareer mode. The disparity between a starting character and a VC-enhanced opponent is stark. Players are left with two primary options: grind extensively to earn VC through gameplay or spend additional money on top of the initial game price. This creates a frustrating dilemma, especially given the game’s annual release cycle and limited lifespan. The review copy included a substantial amount of VC, showcasing the noticeable performance difference between a boosted character and a standard one. This disparity was further highlighted by playing on both Xbox Series X (with VC investment) and Xbox One (without significant VC investment), revealing a significant gap in gameplay experience.
nba-2k23-booker.jpgGameplay in NBA 2K23 is more demanding and skill-based.
Despite the microtransaction issues, NBA 2K23 offers a wealth of content. The Jordan Challenge mode stands out, allowing players to relive iconic moments from Michael Jordan’s career. These challenges feature era-specific visuals and commentary, immersing players in basketball history. MyTeam, the card-collecting mode, is also well-developed and provides a compelling alternative to MyCareer. However, the MyCareer mode itself presents a mixed bag. On older consoles, the story mode is relatively streamlined, allowing players to skip cutscenes and quickly jump into gameplay. On current-gen consoles, however, the experience is bogged down by a sprawling open-world environment called The City. While visually impressive, The City suffers from tedious traversal and an overabundance of non-basketball activities. Players spend an excessive amount of time completing quests and interacting with NPCs, detracting from the core basketball experience.
NBA 2K23 showcases both the best and worst aspects of the series. The enhanced gameplay mechanics and rich content offerings are commendable, but the pervasive microtransactions and cumbersome MyCareer experience on current-gen consoles significantly hinder its potential. If 2K can address these issues and prioritize player experience over monetization, the series could truly reach new heights.
Rating: 3 out of 5
A review code for NBA 2K23 was provided for Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One. This review was primarily conducted on Xbox Series X.
